Hi! Not sure if this is an r/askbaking or r/askculinary question, but it's for a savory dish, so here I am.
I'm trying to recreate my granny's home made dumplings using her recipe (written below) but I'm having trouble with consistency. I can't tell if it's my dough or what the problem is.
Essentially, half of the dumplings end up with an amazing, fluffy texture inside which is tasty and pleasant, and the other half end up gummy and gross. I would like for them all to be fluffy and nice, but I've never managed it. My granny did do things a little different than I've seen other southern-style recipes use, so maybe that's it? Recipe and a few notes from trial an error:
1 cup self rising, white lily branded flour*
4 tablespoons vegetable shortening or lard (I always use shortening)
Pinch of salt and pepper
1 teaspoon sugar
1/4 cup milk, used sparingly
4 cups chicken stock**
shredded chicken meat and whatever veggies you may want (I make mine with just the meat, veggies served separately)
Mix the shortening and flour using the fingertip method until incorporated and the flour looks like crumbs. Transfer to a flat surface, make a little well in the flour, and pour the milk in the well, starting with small amounts and adding more if necessary. Mix until just combined. Roll the dough into a ball and set aside to rest.
Once the stock is just about boiling, start making little rolled balls of dough. 1/2 inch or less. By the time you're done, the stock will be at a rolling boil. Drop all the dough in the pot and poke at it until everything's submerged, but do not stir. The pot should be full! (This might be where I'm going wrong? But it's on her recipe card, that the pot should be full.)
Cook for 10 minutes, do not stir under any circumstances. Take off the heat at 10 minutes, then stir in the shredded meat, serve immediately.
*I'm not particular about the brand of flour, but my granny was, so I try to stick to white lily when available for accuracy purposes.
**Granny always made her stock from scratch and had a supply in the freezer at all times. I usually just buy a carton from the store and call it a day. Could it really make that much difference for the dumpling texture itself? (I know real stock tastes better, but I don't have the room or time that she did to always have homemade on hand.)
Maybe I am overcrowding the pan after all? But again, half the dumplings end up perfect. Which is also why I don't know that my dough itself is an issue, unless maybe I'm using too much shortening?
I don't know. Any thoughts and advice appreciated!