I finished my open water course about 2 weeks ago, and have 13 total dives (4 from OW and 9 after). I have a Hollis ST Elite BP/W setup, with the steel backplate. I like having pockets, and with the Hollis ditchable weight pockets, that's not really an option, they take up too much space on the waist webbing.
I've found that I need very little weight. So far, these dives have been successful with my current BP/W:
- 2 lbs fresh water 80 aluminum + 3/2 mm wet suit
- 0 lbs salt water 100 aluminum - no wet suit
- 2 lbs salt water 80 aluminum - no wet suit
I might even be able to get away with 0 lbs with no wet suit and an AL 80 in salt water, I'm not sure yet. My wet suit isn't a super nice one, it's this cheap 3/2 from Amazon, which I assume means it won't be as buoyant but I'm not certain: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0DBLJXB55?th=1
I'm about to do a salt water dive, in that wet suit, and trying to figure out how to manage weight.
I'm trying to figure out how to have pockets, like I want, but also have enough weight in the right places. So far I've been sticking that 2 lbs in a trim pocket on the top strap of my tank, because I'm foot heavy and it helps counter that. From what I'm finding, I'll need 6-8 lbs in that 3/2 wet suit in salt water.
The issue is mostly around placement, not available pockets for the amount of weight. I have the Hollis ditchable pockets that hold plenty, but they take all of my "belt" webbing space on my BCD. I tried to stick thinner non-ditchable weight pockets next to the normal pockets I wanted to use, but the two together take up enough space that I can't get the belt tight around my waist.
Right now I'm leaning towards sticking all the required weight in two trim pockets on my tank, one low one high, but there's a "smell" to all my weight being non-ditchable, and I'm not sure what to do about that. In an emergency I could pull out weights that were on my waist, even if they weren't quickly ditchable, but there is no way I can reach my back. But it also feels like 6-8 lbs is pretty inconsequential compared to other amounts of weight that I see commonly mentioned here.