r/reactjs Mar 15 '26

Meta Announcement: Requesting Community Feedback on Sub Content Changes

26 Upvotes

We've had multiple complaints lately about the rapid decline in post quality for this sub.

We're opening up this thread to discuss some potential planned changes to our posting rules, with a goal of making the sub more useful.

Mod Background

Hi! I'm acemarke. I've been the only fully active mod for /r/reactjs for a few years now. I'm also a long-standing admin of the Reactiflux Discord, the primary Redux maintainer, and general answerer of questions around React and its ecosystem.

You don't see most of the work I do, because most of it is nuking posts that are either obvious spam / low quality / off-topic.

I also do this in my spare time. I read this sub a lot anyways, so it's easy for me to just say "nope, goodbye", and remove posts. But also, I have a day job, something resembling a life, and definitely need sleep :) So there's only so much I can do in terms of skimming posts and trying to clean things up. Even more than that: as much as I have a well-deserved reputation for popping into threads when someone mentions Redux, I can only read so many threads myself due to time and potential interest.

/u/vcarl has also been a mod for the last couple years, but is less active.

What Content Should We Support?

The primary issue is: what posts and content qualifies as "on-topic" for /r/reactjs?.

We've generally tried to keep the sub focused on technical discussion of using React and its ecosystem. That includes discussions about React itself, libraries, tools, and more. And, since we build things with React, it naturally included people posting projects they'd built.

The various mods over the years have tried to put together guidelines on what qualifies as acceptable content, as seen in the sidebar. As seen in the current rules, our focus has been on behavior. We've tried to encourage civil and constructive discussion.

The actual rules on content currently are:

  • Demos should include source code
  • "Portfolios" are limited to Sundays
  • Posts should be from people, not just AI copy-paste
  • The sub is focused on technical discussions of React, not career topics
  • No commercial posts

But the line is so blurry here. Clearly a discussion of a React API or ecosystem library is on topic, and historically project posts have been too. But where's the line here? Should a first todo list be on-topic? An Instagram clone? Another personal project? Is it okay to post just the project live URL itself, or does it need to have a repo posted too? What about projects that aren't OSS? Where's the line between "here's a thing I made" and blatant abuse of the sub as a tool for self-promotion? We've already limited "portfolio posts" to Sundays - is it only a portfolio if the word "portfolio" is in the submission title? Does a random personal project count as a portfolio? Where do we draw these lines? What's actually valuable for this sub?

Meanwhile, there's also been constant repetition of the same questions. This occurs in every long-running community, all the way back to the days of the early Internet. It's why FAQ pages were invented. The same topics keep coming up, new users ask questions that have been asked dozens of times before. Just try searching for how many times "Context vs Redux vs Zustand vs Mobx" have been debated in /r/reactjs :)

Finally, there's basic code help questions. We previously had a monthly "Code Questions / Beginner's Thread", and tried to redirect direct "how do I make this code work?" questions there. That thread stopped getting any usage, so we stopped making it.

Current Problems

Moderation is fundamentally a numbers problem. There's only so many human moderators available, and moderation requires judgment calls, but those judgment calls require time and attention - far more time and attention than we have.

We've seen a massive uptick in project-related posts. Not surprising, giving the rise of AI and vibe-coding. It's great that people are building things. But seeing an endless flood of "I got tired of X, so I built $PROJECT" or "I built yet another $Y" posts has made the sub much lower-signal and less useful.

So, we either:

  • Blanket allow all project posts
  • Require all project posts to be approved first somehow
  • Auto-mod anything that looks like a project post
  • Or change how projects get posted

(Worth noting that we actually just made the Reactiflux Discord approval-only to join to cut down on spam as well, and are having similar discussions on what changes we should consider to make it a more valuable community and resource.)

Planned Changes

So far, here's what we've got in mind to improve the situation.

First, we've brought in /u/Krossfireo as an additional mod. They've been a longstanding mod in the Reactiflux Discord and have experience dealing with AutoMod-style tools.

Second: we plan to limit all app-style project posts to a weekly megathread. The intended guideline here is:

  • if it's something you would use while building an app, it stays main sub for now
  • if it's any kind of app you built, it goes in the megathread

We'll try putting this in place starting Sunday, March 22.

Community Feedback

We're looking for feedback on multiple things:

  • What kind of content should be on-topic for /r/reactjs? What would be most valuable to discuss and read?
  • Does the weekly megathread approach for organizing project-related posts seem like it will improve the quality of the sub?
  • What other improvements can we make to the sub? Rules, resources, etc

The flip side: We don't control what gets submitted! It's the community that submits posts and replies. If y'all want better content, write it and submit it! :) All we can do is try to weed out the spam and keep things on topic (and hopefully civilized).

The best thing the community can do is flag posts and comments with the "Report" tool. We do already have AutoMod set up to auto-remove any post or comment that has been flagged too many times. Y'all can help here :) Also, flagged items are visibly marked for us in the UI, so they stand out and give an indication that they should be looked at.

FWIW we're happy to discuss how we try to mod, what criteria we should have as a sub, and what our judgment is for particular posts.

It's a wild and crazy time to be a programmer. The programming world has always changed rapidly, and right now that pace of change is pretty dramatic :) Hopefully we can continue to find ways to keep /r/reactjs a useful community and resource!


r/reactjs Jun 03 '26

News Official Rust port of the React Compiler is now available for testing

Thumbnail
github.com
97 Upvotes

r/reactjs 3h ago

Resource Free, open-source UI avatars for React projects 👋

6 Upvotes

If you're working on a React project and need some avatars for profiles, dashboards, user lists, comments, or mock data, here's a collection that might be useful.

There are 200+ free, open-source UI avatars that you can use in your projects.

There's also a UI Avatar Guide on the page if you want to learn more about using avatars in interfaces.

🔗 https://radianui.com/resources/avatar

Sharing it in case it's useful for anyone working on a React project!


r/reactjs 20h ago

Discussion What’s the real problem with useEffect in React?

46 Upvotes

Here is my honest question:

What's the actual problem with the useEffect hook? All over the X/twitter, I see a lot of negativity about this hook. It seems like a buggy thing in React.

My opinion is that developers blame useEffect because it's often used for data fetching as the primary use case. As we deal with various states like loading, data, error etc… synchronization of these causes bugs.

Also, a misunderstanding of the rendering cycle in React, such as where useEffect gets called could introduce additional misuses and bugs.

Hence, just saying useEffect is evil, may not be the right assumption is what I think. But, there could be cases that I'm missing.

What's your take or opinion about it?


r/reactjs 14h ago

Show /r/reactjs How far would you push feature isolation in a large React component library?

Thumbnail
github.com
3 Upvotes

A month ago I posted AdaptTable here. Since then the feature surface has grown quite a bit, and one of the more interesting problems has been keeping all of that optional functionality from turning the main table into one huge bundle.

Some of the heavier capabilities now have their own entry points:

@adapttable/core/xlsx
@adapttable/core/pdf
@adapttable/core/formula
@adapttable/core/pivot
@adapttable/core/stream
@adapttable/core/sparkline

The React adapters are moving in the same direction:

@adapttable/mantine/row-reorder
@adapttable/mantine/grouping
@adapttable/mantine/editing
@adapttable/mantine/virtualize
@adapttable/mantine/cell-navigation

The core entries already avoid the bundle cost unless they’re imported.
The adapter side is not completely there yet because some optional feature implementations are still reachable from the root DataTable import graph.

In v3 I’m moving those implementations out so the application only pays for the features it actually imports.

I’m also separating the framework-neutral engine logic from the React hooks/components, which should eventually make Vue and Angular bindings possible without duplicating the table engine.

For people who maintain larger React libraries: how far would you take this?

At what point do lots of feature-specific entry points become more annoying for users than the bundle-size savings are worth?

For context, this is the project:
GitHub⁠ · Live demo⁠ · v1 → v2.9 write-up


r/reactjs 16h ago

Needs Help Should I rewrite this widget from scratch or build inside the existing Next.js app?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/reactjs 16h ago

Show /r/reactjs Show r/reactjs: a no-backend AI image comparison tool, React + TypeScript, MIT

0 Upvotes

Built this as a React and TypeScript single-page app with no server at all. It runs one prompt across up to 13 image models and shows the results in a grid so you can compare instead of guess.

React-specific bits that might interest people: all state is local (IndexedDB for images and metadata, localStorage for keys), the provider layer is a set of adapters behind one interface so a new provider is one file, and a strict CSP limits fetch to the provider domains, which forced some decisions about how errors surface in the UI. There's a light table component for marking up a contact sheet that I'm reasonably happy with.

MIT, single maintainer, happy to answer questions on the architecture.

Repo: https://github.com/hirashif/gridloom
Live: https://gridloom.app

What do people use for local-first persistence in React these days? I went straight IndexedDB and would do it differently next time.


r/reactjs 1d ago

Best Fully Open-Source Spreadsheet Component for React with Excel Import/Export?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm looking for a fully open-source spreadsheet component for React.

I do not want a paid/commercial library or a library where important spreadsheet features require a paid license.

I need something closer to Excel / Google Sheets, rather than just a data grid.

Main requirements:

  • Fully open source and usable in a commercial project
  • React + TypeScript support
  • Import .xlsx Excel files
  • Export to .xlsx
  • Preserve Excel formatting as much as possible
  • Formulas and calculations
  • Multiple worksheets
  • Cell formatting
  • Merge/unmerge cells
  • Copy/paste
  • Sorting and filtering
  • Data validation/dropdowns
  • Freeze rows/columns
  • Undo/redo
  • Insert/delete/resize rows and columns
  • Good performance with larger worksheets
  • API for programmatically reading/updating cells
  • Custom toolbar/components
  • Extensible enough to implement drag-and-drop elements/components into spreadsheet cells

I've already looked at Univer and FortuneSheet, but I'm trying to find the best option with strong Excel import/export support.

My ideal flow is:

Import existing .xlsx → Edit in React → Export back to .xlsx

without losing important formulas, formatting, worksheets, merged cells, etc.

What is the best fully open-source React spreadsheet library in 2026 for this?

If you're using one in production, I'd really appreciate hearing about its limitations, especially around Excel import/export.

Thanks!


r/reactjs 1d ago

Show /r/reactjs Electron React App v13: the IPC boilerplate is gone

19 Upvotes

Introducing a new major update for the "Electron React App" desktop app's starter kit.

Let's talk about the worst part of building Electron apps. You want to minimize a window from a button. So you write a handler in main. Then invent a channel name. Then add a preload bridge entry. Then declare the types. Then finally make the call in the renderer. Five files for one button, and the whole thing silently rots the day you rename something.

v13 throws that out. You define the feature once in main, and the renderer just has it. Typed, auto-completed, React hooks attached. No channel strings anywhere.

Read more about the new changes in the Repository page:
https://github.com/guasam/electron-react-app

Feature Highlights:

- Type-safe IPC: queries, commands, streams, and events, inferred end to end
- Cross-window state owned by main, synced live, with opt-in persistence
- Sandboxed renderer with a two-line preload
- Custom window frame, titlebar, and menus with keyboard shortcuts
- Light and dark theme
- React error boundary with detailed dev reporting
- Import path aliases for app, lib, conveyor, and resources
- Shadcn UI on Radix, styled with TailwindCSS
- Vite HMR, with ESLint and Prettier preconfigured
- VS Code debug configs for both main and renderer
- electron-builder packaging for Windows, macOS, and Linux

If you were starting an Electron app tomorrow, what would you want already handled for you?


r/reactjs 1d ago

I thought it was a nice idea but I am back to reality now. Shelving it for now and keep learning from it.

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

So, I thought it would work out but with surveyjs and RJSF it seems to be a bad idea but still I built something that I can learn from. Maintenance is difficult and fear of what if one bug will destroy the whole initiative and always overpowers the chances of being successful.


r/reactjs 2d ago

Show /r/reactjs Ambient CSS v3 - Blender meets CSS

Thumbnail
ambientcss.vercel.app
62 Upvotes

I started building a physically based shadow system for CSS 5 years back and gave up after it became too complex. Then, leveraging coding agents, I was finally able to ship v1 earlier this year. Thanks to the very kind and warm reception for v1 from the members of this community and r/css , I was motivated to develop it further.

Today, I'm announcing Ambient CSS v3. This version steps up the realism considerably - each effect and base component was first built in Blender and rendered using an identical lighting setup. Then, based on the renders the CSS formulae were adjusted to match the Blender render. All the Blender files and their parametric generators are also in the source repo.

Besides this, we also have new CSS modifiers - thickness, material (matte/shiny/glass/brushed/spun/blasted). We also have some new components for the react package. Also, the component system is refactored and split into base components and skins, allowing for the ability to create custom component kits.

Thanks for your love!


r/reactjs 2d ago

Resource react-props-parser | Alternative react docgen parser (ts supported) for Storybook

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

For a while now, I have been working with React and Storybook libraries. react-docgen and react-docgen-typescript libraries are the supported libraries by Sitecore to extract metadata and populate the arg table with jsdoc comments and types.

As components' types grew more complex, react-docgen and react-docgen-typescript stopped giving me enough. They're good libraries, but they often fail to parse jsdoc comments and interfaces correctly, forcing me to manually override ArgTypes — which means duplicating information in both the type files and the Storybook files.

I was looking for some ideas to implement with AI, and it pushed me to build a new docgen parser. My main goals were parsing union types more accurately, making sure JSDoc comments always show up and letting me see the full structure of an interface without leaving Storybook.

Part of the motivation is also that the two main tools we have - react-docgen and react-docgen-typescript — haven't been updated in 6 months to a year.

This is my first open source project. I plan to keep improving it and maintain it long-term if people find it useful and see a future in it.

Link: https://www.npmjs.com/package/react-props-parser

I'd like you to test whether you are using Storybook and TypeScript, and share your feedback if the output is better for you compared to the default parsers.

If you let me know what breaks, what's missing, or what you'd want changed, I can turn around fixes quickly. Many thanks beforehand!


r/reactjs 1d ago

Show /r/reactjs I open sourced a free Next.js analytics dashboard starter built with HonestUI and ECharts

0 Upvotes

I've been working on HonestUI, and I wanted a real project to test the components against instead of making more isolated demos.

So I built this Next.js analytics dashboard starter and open sourced it.

It uses HonestUI for the UI and charts, with ECharts underneath the chart components. The starter has working date filters, revenue views, customer search and filtering, retention data, responsive navigation, loading states, and dark mode.

There is no auth or backend wired in. The data is static on purpose so the repo stays easy to clone and change.

I also tried to avoid the usual dashboard template where everything is a separate card with a number in it. I wanted it to look closer to an actual SaaS product.

Demo: https://dashboard-template.honestui.com

GitHub: https://github.com/honestui/honestui-dashboard

I'd be interested in feedback on the starter itself, especially anything you'd expect to be included before you'd actually use something like this for a new project.


r/reactjs 2d ago

What would make a component unmount on some parent renders but not others when the key isn't changing?

5 Upvotes

I've got a filter panel in a Vite app on React 18 where the date inputs wipe themselves maybe one time in five when the parent list refetches. I've ruled out the usual cause, the child isn't declared inside the parent's render body, and the key I pass it is a stable string. I put a log in the child's mount effect and it fires every time the fields clear, so it's actually remounting rather than losing state some other way. I've been on this about three hours and I can't work out what's different about the renders where it happens.


r/reactjs 3d ago

I created ascii/cnlibs - an ascii shadcn/ui component library

Thumbnail
ascii.cnlibs.com
56 Upvotes

r/reactjs 3d ago

Needs Help What does "rendering in background" in startTransition really mean?

25 Upvotes

So far, I understand that wrapping a function with startTransition tells React to treat it as a non‑urgent update. So if any urgent action occurs, React can respond to it immediately without blocking.

But here is where I got stuck. The docs say:

“useTransition is a React Hook that lets you render a part of the UI in the background.”

“The function passed to startTransition is called the Action. You can update state and (optionally) perform side effects within an Action, and the work will be done in the background without blocking user interactions.”

I don’t really get what “in the background” really means.

Looking at the example, I don’t understand why, with startTransition, the “Total” only renders once with the final "Total" after clicking “quantity” multiple times, instead of updating multiple times according to the number of times the “quantity” was clicked

Does “run in background” prevent multiple renders and only show the final result??


r/reactjs 3d ago

Needs Help I built a dev tool that shows mobile, tablet, and desktop simultaneously in your browser: synced scroll, click, and input across all three

4 Upvotes

Been using Responsively App for a while but the context

switching was getting to me — separate window, separate

process, alt-tab constantly.

Built responsive-dx to solve it. It's an npm dev dependency

that injects a synchronized multi-viewport panel directly

into your localhost.

One command to set it up:

npx responsive-dx init

It detects your framework automatically (Next.js, Vite,

Remix, Astro, Gatsby) and adds the component to your layout

file. Nothing to configure manually.

What it does:

- Mobile, tablet, and desktop frames side-by-side

- Scroll one → they all scroll (real DOM sync, not emulation)

- Click syncs, input syncs, dark/light theme syncs

- Focus mode: one click to zoom any single frame

- iPhone notch on mobile, macOS chrome on desktop

The frames load any localhost URL — so even though the

wrapper is React, it works for Vue, Svelte, Angular, Rails,

Django, whatever you're running locally.

Zero dependencies. Tree-shaken out of production builds

completely.

GitHub: https://github.com/respodx/respo

npm: https://www.npmjs.com/package/responsive-dx

Happy to answer any technical questions.


r/reactjs 4d ago

Needs Help Can anyone clarify the concept of "reusable state" in Concurrent React?

28 Upvotes

I’m reading the React docs, but I find this passage confusing. Could someone explain it to me?

"Another example is reusable state. Concurrent React can remove sections of the UI from the screen, then add them back later while reusing the previous state. For example, when a user tabs away from a screen and back, React should be able to restore the previous screen in the same state it was in before."

React docs link


r/reactjs 4d ago

Show /r/reactjs I built a streaming Markdown renderer for React that caches code lines, table rows and list items — benchmarks are surprisingly good

3 Upvotes

I’ve been working on an AI harness called Æven, and one of the things that kept bothering me was Markdown rendering during long streamed responses.

A lot of renderers optimize at the document or top-level block level. That works well for normal prose, but it gets expensive when the active block itself becomes huge — for example a long code fence or a large Markdown table.

So I built HyperMarkdown.

The main idea is pretty simple:

once a code line, table row or list item is settled, it stays cached. Only the changing frontier keeps being parsed/rendered.

That seems to make a pretty significant difference.

Current benchmark results:

  • Large code block: 190 ms vs 711 ms for the next closest streaming renderer
  • Captured real AI code stream: 611 ms vs 4.2 s
  • Captured real AI table stream: 668 ms vs 5.0 s
  • Large table: 999 ms vs 9.1 s for the next closest renderer

The benchmark runs production React and measures the full chunk → write → render/commit path, not just parsing.

I’ve compared it against:

  • markstream-react
  • Streamdown
  • DeepSeek Harness’ incremental strategy
  • react-markdown
  • markdown-it as a baseline

The repo includes the benchmark methodology, raw results and correctness tests, so I’d genuinely appreciate people trying to break the assumptions or point out unfair comparisons.

It also supports GFM, reasoning blocks, syntax highlighting, KaTeX, Mermaid, raw HTML sanitization, React 18/19, and streaming incomplete Markdown.

It’s now the renderer I use inside Æven.

Demo:
https://aeven-ai.github.io/HyperMarkdown/

GitHub:
https://github.com/Aeven-AI/HyperMarkdown

NPM:
https://www.npmjs.com/package/@aeven-ai/hypermarkdown

Would especially love feedback from people who have dealt with long streamed code blocks/tables in React apps.


r/reactjs 4d ago

I’m building an open-source Canvas-based document editor with a React adapter

11 Upvotes

Hey r/reactjs,

I've been working on Oasis Editor, an open-source TypeScript document editor with its own Canvas-based rendering engine.

React sits on top as an adapter rather than owning the editor runtime, so the same core can be used from vanilla JS, Vue, or headless environments.

The editor handles paged layout, text rendering, selections, images, tables, and document geometry through its own rendering pipeline, and exposes a typed command/plugin API.

Live playground:
https://celsowm.github.io/oasis-editor/#/editor

GitHub:
https://github.com/celsowm/oasis-editor

I'd love feedback on the React integration, API design, and overall architectu


r/reactjs 4d ago

Needs Help How would you handle uploading to a presigned upload URL, on paste, getting a download URL back and immediately displaying it in an input? (In S3)

12 Upvotes

I want in my practice chat app to be able to paste an image into a text input and be able to send it, on how to actually do this, I am unsure

My idea is this given a text input:

- a user could Ctrl-V (i.e., paste) something from his clipboard (a file in this instance), until a download url is returned (see below) there will be some loader spinner thingy
- In the backend is requested an Upload URL
- (somehow) whatever they pasted is immediately uploaded, likely by the path? But I am still a little bit unsure on that part
- a Download URL is returned on that S3 upload (SOMEHOW)
And thus you replace that temporary spinner with the download URL and the person can send it.

This is at least my idea on how you should be able to upload a piece of media in a message and be able to send it, I don't want just message attachments, that would be an easier story because once the association is made between the message and attachment you display it. I want something like in forums where the image can be embedded anywhere,

There is also one more small concern, on slow connection do you want to wait for the file to finish uploading first and then allow the user to send their message, or just send the message and let the upload come later, if the latter, how would you go across with doing that!?

The issue is, I have no idea on how to do this, I gave my approach above, I would really appreciate it if you guys gave some advice on what your approach would be and secondly, how to implement it, I already can get a presigned URL so that's not an issue

This is more of a design question, but it's also really interlinked with react so sorry if this is the wrong place to ask! ;-;

That's all :)


r/reactjs 5d ago

Resource Static Analysis for the Age of AI Slop

26 Upvotes

I recently wrote a blog post on how we can improve our static analysis using linting, custom rules, and hooks, all using oxlint.

It's quite a big article btw.

https://saybackend.com/blog/lint-ai-generated-code/


r/reactjs 4d ago

Needs Help I tried removing translation keys from React i18n — Zintl is now in alpha

0 Upvotes

I've always found translation keys a little strange.

You start with something perfectly readable:

tsx <button>Delete account</button>

Then i18n turns it into something like:

tsx <button>{t("settings.account.delete")}</button>

Now the source code, translation keys, and translation files all have to stay synchronized.

So I tried a different approach with Zintl:

What if the source string itself could be the thing the localization system knows about?

With Zintl, you keep writing normal application code:

tsx <h1>Welcome back</h1> <p>Your account is ready.</p> <button>Continue</button>

Zintl's compiler discovers the localizable strings and builds the localization layer around them.

The goal is that adding i18n shouldn't mean rewriting your application around t() calls.

It's currently alpha, so I'm very much not claiming this is production-ready.

I'm looking for React developers who have actually dealt with i18n to try it and tell me where this approach falls apart.

Especially interested in:

  • translation key management
  • dynamic/interpolated strings
  • component boundaries
  • pluralization
  • large applications
  • translation workflows/TMS
  • anything you think a compiler like this should handle

Docs: https://zintljs.github.io/zintl/en

I'd genuinely love the criticism. If you think the whole idea is flawed, tell me why.


r/reactjs 4d ago

Resource IconMind: 2,271 MIT icons for AI-era apps (agents, MCP, RAG) as tree-shakable React components — 1 kB gz per icon

0 Upvotes

One icon = one import = ~1.1 kB gzipped (import { AgentRun } from "@iconmind/react/icons/agent-run"), sideEffects: false, every icon its own entry so React.lazy has something to load. Outline and duotone, three weights, strokeWidth/absoluteStrokeWidth props. The AI vocabulary is the point — the generalist families are there so you don't need Lucide beside it (and a hundred Lucide names resolve as aliases if you do). MCP server for your assistant: npx u/iconmind/mcp. https://iconmind.dev


r/reactjs 4d ago

Discussion I built a React UI library with two install models. Does this split make sense?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

I read the recent thread here about what would make people try another React component library. A few answers stuck with me, especially composability, accessibility, and components that hold up outside of demo data.

I've been building Honest UI, and there is one decision I keep going back and forth on.

UI components and animated components get copied into your project. Once they're there, they're just source files. You can change the markup, behavior, variants, or styling however you want.

Charts, icons, logos, vectors, and shaders stay package imports.

My thinking is that application UI usually becomes product code pretty fast. A button or form field rarely stays generic once you start adding validation, permissions, loading states, weird content, and all the edge cases that show up later.

Charts and shaders feel different to me. They bring more rendering code and dependencies with them, and I would rather maintain that in one package. Copying a huge icon or logo collection into every project also seems unnecessary.

The part I'm unsure about is whether this split is useful or if it just makes the library harder to explain.

I made a short demo showing both approaches with real components.

Does this boundary make sense to you? Would you split it somewhere else?

If you think the whole idea is backwards, I want to hear that too.