r/law 19h ago

Executive Branch (Trump) Judge demands answers from DHS as teen deported twice this year in violation of court orders

https://talkingpointsmemo.com/morning-memo/first-at-tpm-teen-deported-twice-this-year-in-violation-of-multiple-court-orders
1.7k Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 19h ago

All new posts must have a brief statement from the user submitting explaining how their post relates to law or the courts in a response to this comment. FAILURE TO PROVIDE A BRIEF RESPONSE MAY RESULT IN REMOVAL. Please post your statement as a reply to this automated message.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (2)

227

u/petitecrivain 19h ago

You'd get better results from taking action. Hold them in contempt and throw them in jail for however long it takes to comply. I'm sure the administration agrees with that tactic!

87

u/ZoomZoom_Driver 18h ago

Yup. They'll just keep violating court orders until those violations come with CONSEQUENCES.

Sonfar. America seems to have a problem with republicans meeting the consequences of their actions, even illegal and unconstitutional ones like a coup.

27

u/Lonely_skeptic 18h ago

Jail. The DOJ will run out of conscienceless lawyers.

8

u/ZoomZoom_Driver 17h ago

Oh, noes, the DOJ would have zero people to send to court over their lawless actions, meaning the presumption would be on thebside ofnWe the People against our gov...

Oh, noes!!!! Well, anyways...

17

u/Additional-Sky-7436 18h ago

Whoever shows up, regardless how low on the totem poll they might be, throw that person in jail until the situation is rectified. 

If low level people think there will be consequences for "just doing my job" then they will do just doing the job.

2

u/Ok-Suggestion3534 16h ago

Nothing will happen until necks are hanging from trees. 

42

u/boringhistoryfan 18h ago

Yes. Keep asking questions. That'll get them to stop.

JFC you'd be forgiven for thinking these aren't judges but jellyfish in robes. What is even the point of contempt power in an adversarial system when you're never going to use it against the state? Federal judges have no problems whatsoever holding defendants in contempt. Start tossing the US attorneys and their litigator subordinates into jail. Start ordering the arrest of noncompliant DHS officials.

Or stop pretending you've got a system of justice here.

7

u/Hesitation-Marx 17h ago

Imagine if us common rabble got this kind of judicial authority.

57

u/sweatboxy 19h ago

Can I too just violate court orders when I want to?

7

u/Macat921 14h ago

That depends, how much money do you have?

11

u/ramonlamone 18h ago

Sure. But you can bet that someone is going to "demand answers", and they'll probably even send you a strongly worded letter suggesting that what you're doing isn't right. Checks and balances, you know.

I don't know, maybe "demand answers" is the new legal term for "send more money and I'll look the other way"?

2

u/soupseasonbestseason 14h ago

none of our clients at the p.d. can...

11

u/jwr1111 19h ago

Hateful, smug, horrible people.

Many Americans are saying... good people...

11

u/TeekTheReddit 16h ago

Stop demanding answers and start putting them in fucking jail.

19

u/TellTaleTimeLord 18h ago

Every judge in the country: "why are you breaking the law?"

The government: "because we can"

The judges: "you only get one more of those"

The government: one more of those

The judges: "im going to consider potentially thinking about maybe holding you in contempt for that"

9

u/Playful-Dragon 17h ago

Their answer... we don't give a fuck

13

u/ledude1 19h ago

Now the court version of a strongly worded letter. SMFHO.

6

u/RellenD 16h ago

Judges have to start putting lawyers in the court jail

5

u/Ging287 16h ago

Hold the show cause hearings.