r/extremelyinfuriating • u/Q_dawgg • 5h ago
Disturbing content Western moral posturing about the Afghan “Bacha Bazi” phenomenon is inherently hypocritical.
Obligatory disclaimer for sensitive and distressing content. Please don’t continue reading if topics regarding abuse, specifically systematic abuse upsets you. I would also like to clarify, I consider myself pro-western and pro-secular on just about every topic. I’m from the west and I’ve just been studying our war in Afghanistan quite a bit lately. I also disagree with this cultural practice completely. My only contention is with our coverage of this phenomenon in the west.
So for those of you lucky enough not to know, Bacha Bazi is a Central Asian/Afghan pederastic practice in which young boys are coerced into sexual abuse by influential adult men. It’s been a practice for centuries and has popped up throughout history in the region.
Western media outlets have taken it upon themselves to, ad nauseam, inform the public on this practice and what it usually entails, this is usually done with an intention to display the inherent “barbarism” in Afghan cultures, and larger Muslim societies.
I’ve seen podcasts, news reports, and internet debates bringing up this phenomenon constantly—-and almost all of them conveniently ignore the fact that our western coalition outright revived the “Bacha Bazi” phenomenon with our invasion of Afghanistan. When it was previously outlawed!
I learned of this quite recently when researching the legal administration of the Taliban when they first came to power, apparently, the practice of “Bacha Bazi” had been outlawed by the Taliban when they first took power. Most instances of this practice occurring at the time, took place within the territory of the Northern Alliance, the very coalition who we supported when we invaded the country.
When the formal Afghan government was established, the practice was outlawed on paper, but in reality, Afghan field commanders who fought alongside us practiced “Bacha Bazi” on numerous children across Afghanistan. And though it was controversial, it basically occurred constantly throughout the war.
For western media and podcasters to highlight this practice as an Afghan phenomenon, without mentioning the fact that we basically spurred it back into existence and let it continue is insane and hypocritical to me. It’s also an example of how our current political debates are absolutely braindead.
I don’t even think most westerners realize we were the ones to bring this practice back to life.
Obviously our governments and military weren’t pro-pedophile. And the Taliban are certainly not a morally “good” entity. But the western coverage of this issue is completely unethical and washes away the very real role we as a coalition had in this practice.
