I've been on this journey of making my mac workflow more Keyboard-Driven.
There is no shortage of tools out there, native and third party. We can naively categorize the ecosystem into two approaches:
Manual snapping/switching: Tools like Rectangle, Alt-Tab... etc. You manually snap windows into halves/thirds,..., but switching between arbitrary windows still relies on cycling linearly through an Alt-Tab like list of some sort, or using Mission Control/mouse.
Automatic tiling window managers: Tools like Yabai, AeroSpace, or Amethyst. They give you powerful keyboard focus (navigating directionally with h/j/k/l or arrow keys), but they force everything into rigid, automatic grids,BSP trees, i3-style splits, forced full-screening, and strict layouts.
A lot of keyboard-first enthusiasts seem to gravitate towards and recommend automatic tiling management. I’ve tried (yabai, AeroSpace) but couldn't get used to this approach. I found it hijacks the desktop more than I could tolerate, forcing tiling and not letting me just adjust one window's size for example.
What I actually want is much simpler: say manual tiling is fine, if I'm focused on a window, I hit the right arrow (or l, or whatever), I want the focus to move to the window that is physically to the right of the one I'm on, in a spatial/directional, not sequential manner. The window that’s actually on the right side of the window I'm on (or the most reasonable spatial candidate if things are not perfectly aligned/overlapping).
Just navigation through space on the standard, free-form desktop, the way the eyes already scan the screen. Kind of like old/simple video games where you just move with the arrows, you don't think about it much you just go there.
Anyone found something that does that (directional nav) without the rigid "management" tradeoff, or has everyone just accepted the grid is unavoidable?